Saif Gaddafi’s Flirtations with Reform were Just That


saif.jpgSaif Gaddafi has probably just assured the civil war he warned against in his finger-wagging comments that security forces would fight protesters down to the last bullet. Leading tribal chiefs inside Libya have called out for the Gaddafi government to show restraint and to back off, condemning government for the violence against those mourning at funerals and the indiscriminate shooting and shelling of unarmed crowds by snipers and from helicopters. Hundreds have been slaughtered and many thousands injured.
What is interesting is that Saif Gaddafi is no idiot. He has seen for some time that his father’s government was brittle and fragile — and that a spark could come along and unleash internal rage against those holding incumbent power.
Much to the distress and private anger of Libyan leader Moammer Gaddafi’s chief internal security and military czars, Saif Gaddafi has led a domestic campaign of reconciliation and bridge-building with the Muslim Brotherhood, considered at that time to be the regime’s chief political opponent. At Saif’s urging and with grudging support from his father, various former leaders of the Libyan Islamic Fighting Group had been appointed to various key government and semi-government positions of responsibility.
When I was in Libya, three of the LIFG’s top tier — the Emir of the group as well as the head of planning, and of armaments — were taken off of death row and released. I was there and met them and watched the discomfort of the chief of internal security as this was happening. Saif was trying to make the police state his father had built relax its grip and to reconcile with many of those it feared.
Thus, while I am no fan of Gaddafi, the full story of the revolution inside Libya can’t be told without understanding that Saif Gaddafi, a likely successor to his father, believed in certain kinds of reforms and inclusion early — but given the tenor, the arrogance, and distance from reality he exhibited in his televised comments, he showed that he doesn’t understand the public grievances driving this revolution.
There is little hope that any of these regimes in the Middle East really understand what an inclusive, non-totalitarian regime would really look like.
— Steve Clemons


8 comments on “Saif Gaddafi’s Flirtations with Reform were Just That

  1. Lorne Marr says:

    What will change if one dictator is changed for another? If the people of Libya are not given the chance to choose their own leaders the revolution in this country will not make any sense.


  2. questions says:

    From kos:
    “Benghazi: Troops defect, cities liberated by the protesters
    The major protest in Libya have been occurring in Benghazi, Libya


  3. questions says:

    “In a sign of growing cracks within the government, several senior officials


  4. questions says:



  5. Paul Norheim says:

    “20.01 (GMT): Ominous news from our colleagues over at
    BBC Monitoring: “‘Libyan military source confirms orders
    were issued for the aerial bombardment of Benghazi within
    two hours,'” reported Al-Arabiya TV in an urgent screen
    caption at 19.47 GMT.” (BBC)


  6. Paul Norheim says:

    Are we witnessing something akin to Hitler’s last days –
    ordering Albert Speer to destroy everything that is left, because
    the German people didn’t “deserve” “der F


  7. Paul Norheim says:

    “1628: Journalist in Istanbul, Turkey, Isin Elicin, tweets: “A retired
    judge in Benghazi, said: We have buried today 11 bodies of
    soldiers who refused to fire on civilians.” (BBC)
    These soldiers are among the unknown heros of the revolution in
    Libya, regardless of the outcome.


  8. Paul Norheim says:

    “1719:(GMT) Col Gaddafi’s son, Saif al-Islam, has ordered the
    formation of an investigation committee, headed by a Libyan
    judge with the participation of Libyan and foreign rights groups,
    to investigate the circumstances of the deaths in the recent
    protests, Libyan TV has said.” (BBC)
    Looks like he’s still there, desperately trying to save the
    crumbling regime.


Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *