Reflections on the USS Liberty and Gilad Shalit: Disproportionate Response
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/948f6/948f6ba413f2e01bd7758c48232287336201bbbd" alt=""
A group of armed Palestinians, some connected to the militant wing of Hamas, did penetrate Israel’s border security and did kidnap a young soldier, Gilad Shalit. Those who defend the action say that it was in response to Israel’s killing 7 members of an innocent Palestinian family.