States vs. Transnational Networks and Movements

-

Kenichi Ohmae, one of Japan’s better known elder futurists, once wrote a best-seller, Borderless World — which thought through what eventually became known as globalization and the integration that has come to some corners of the world with the information age. His primary thesis was that states, as we once knew them, would erode in favor of much larger regional blocs and systems of international management and institutions.
States seem to have struck back, particularly since 9/11, with bigger police and intelligence operations, larger fortress systems for deterring bad guys and screening normal humans from evil-doers, more responsibilities for home security and national defense, and so on. But it is essentially the state vs. the non-state Islamic movement that has long been a feature of the Middle East, and as Robert Dreyfuss has written in his intriguing history of American engagement in the Middle East, Devil’s Game: How the United States Helped Unleash Fundamentalist Islam, the United States and Britain have long been on the side of fueling illiberal Islamist movements as a counter-current to nationalist governments in the Middle East, many of which chose to affiliate their interests with the former Soviet Union.
Now, the transnational movements that the West helped fund have matured and are wreaking havoc in a cycle of historic blowback. Nick Kristoff gets at this tension between states and non-state movements like Hezbollah in an interesting article in the New York Times today titled “Feeding the Enemy“.
At the conclusion of his piece, Kristoff writes:

Plenty of experience shows that Israel can’t deter private terror networks, but that it can deter states. Syria, for example, despises Israel but doesn’t launch rockets or kidnap soldiers. So Israel might benefit from firmer states in Lebanon and Gaza that actually control their territories. Instead, the latest Israeli offensives foster anarchy to both the north and the south, potentially nurturing militant groups that are not subject to classical deterrence.
If Israel is ever to achieve real security, we have a pretty good idea how it will be achieved: the kind of two-state solution reached in the private Geneva accord of 2003 between Arab and Israeli peaceniks. The fighting in Lebanon pushes that possibility even farther away — and in that sense, each bombing mission harms Israel’s future as well as Lebanon’s.

Kristoff is, in part, wrong — in my view — about Israel’s ability to deter terror networks. (although my new colleague at the New America Foundation and Century Foundation Daniel Levy disagrees with me on this point).
When I was in Jerusalem in March of this year and meeting with intelligence and other leading national political figures in Israel, a close advisor to Ariel Sharon and subsequently Ehud Olmert said the following:

We know from listening in to conversations between Hamas members that they have given up firing up Qassam rockets. They finally get it. If they fire one off, they usually hit nothing at all — and one of their guys gets his head blown off. We know they don’t do it now. It’s Islamic Jihad that continues to be a problem, but they are disorganized and Hamas one of these days will deal with them. But we know that these guys in Hamas are ultimately rational and aren’t all out to martyr themselves.”

Israel seems to have developed a system of deterrence with Hamas that worked — and leading Israelis recognized Hamas’s calculation of interests.
Israel is now running the risk of failing to find effective and “scaled” strategies of response and deterrence to deal with Hezbollah and is instead running the risk of outraging states — states that thus far have demonstrated profound restraint in reaction to what Israel has been unleashing in the region.
As it stands now, Israel is legitimating and helping Hezbollah’s profile and stature to grow — in a potential state context — rather than working to isolate and delegitimate Hezbollah as a failed movement that Lebanese should definitively reject.
Kristoff also mentions that with regard to a final deal between the Israelis and Palestinians, nearly everyone agrees that a final deal will look something like the well-known Geneva Initiative, which only gets 35% support from israelis when the words “Geneva” are attached to the poll, but which secures 65% of Israeli support when just the key principles of Geneva are tested for support.
I agree with Kristoff that this path is probably the right direction, and the U.S., Europe, Egypt, the Saudis, the Russians, and the UN for the most part know the same. It’s about time to get back on a constructive path and put it to Israel to develop strategies that both secure its national safety while at the same time understanding that there is no safety and stability without resolving the launch of a credible Palestinian state.
I am in Pittsburgh today and New York tomorrow, doing some work and planning with Daniel Levy, who actually wrote under the wing of former Israeli Justice Minister Yossi Beilin the Israeli part of the “Geneva Initiative” mentioned in the Kristoff article. On Thursday of this week, Daniel Levy will be formally announced as a joint fellow of the New America Foundation and Century Foundation and director of a joint Middle East Initiative.
More later.
— Steve Clemons

Comments

14 comments on “States vs. Transnational Networks and Movements

  1. acomplia weight loss says:

    Acomplia represents one of the latest and indeed a most novel method for controlling body weight. Acomplia operates by being a cannabinoid receptor antagonist. This means that Acomplia prevents the normal action of endogenous cannabinoid in the brain from stimulating the so-called CB1 receptors.
    http://www.onlinepharmacy.ws/cart.php?action=view&id=672

    Reply

  2. lending tree says:

    hmm.. i like your idea

    Reply

  3. lending tree says:

    thanks alot.. i really like your blogs

    Reply

  4. web hosting says:

    Hi, very interesting site. I really like it.
    http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/business_company_hosting_site_web/ business company hosting site web http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/hosting_reseller/ hosting reseller http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/company_hosting_start_web/ company hosting start web http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/hosting_mysql/ hosting mysql http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/web_site_hosting_orlando/ web site hosting orlando http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/free_server_hosting/ free server hosting http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/adult_hosting/ adult hosting http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/company_web_site_hosting_service/ company web site hosting service http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/australian_hosting_web/ australian hosting web http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/company_hosting_india_web/ company hosting india web http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/hosting_image_script/ hosting image script http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/announced_hosting_news_provider_web/ announced hosting news provider web http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/internet_hosting/ internet hosting http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/broward_company_hosting_web/ broward company hosting web http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/dedicated_hosting_web/ dedicated hosting web http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/free_hosting_site_web_web/ free hosting site web web http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/album_hosting_image_online_photo/ album hosting image online photo http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/virtual_web_hosting/ virtual web hosting http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/multi_domain_web_hosting/ multi domain web hosting http://coolhosts.awardspace.com/free_mud_hosting/ free mud hosting

    Reply

  5. popup blocker says:

    Hi, very interesting site. I really like it.
    http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/blue_book_for_popup_camper/ blue book for popup camper http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/blocker_pop_uninstall_up/ blocker pop uninstall up http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/aol_pop_up_blocker/ aol pop up blocker http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/advertising_popup/ advertising popup http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/used_four_wheel_popup_campers_for_sale/ used four wheel popup campers for sale http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/advanced_popup_killer/ advanced popup killer http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/best_free_popup_stopper/ best free popup stopper http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/rockwood_popup_camper_part/ rockwood popup camper part http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/4.3_blocker_popup_super/ 4.3 blocker popup super http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/anti_popup_yahoo/ anti popup yahoo http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/stop_porn_popup/ stop porn popup http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/block_messenger_popup/ block messenger popup http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/eliminator_free_popup/ eliminator free popup http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/blocker_popup_test/ blocker popup test http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/block_google_popup/ block google popup http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/ad_killer_popup_stopper_download_free_pop_up_blocker/ ad killer popup stopper download free pop up blocker http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/camper_pickup_popup/ camper pickup popup http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/free_ad_popup_killer/ free ad popup killer http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/bar_blocker_pop_tool_up/ bar blocker pop tool up http://popupblocker.awardspace.com/global_playe_pop_popup_video_ww3.komotv.com/ global playe pop popup video ww3.komotv.com

    Reply

  6. Carl says:

    Do you seriously believe that the decisions being made by the US leadership have anything to do with the concept of a nation-state? Get over it. We’re bought and sold by forces that control our “leaders” with money. There is no basis whatsoever for asserting that the violence we are perpetrating in Irag or the torture we inflict at Guantanamo are anything but the mad schemes of those who want nothing better than to kill or die for money or g*d. Watch our pathetic liberties further weakened and flushed down the toilet with propaganda and fear and tell me that this has anything to do with the founding principles of this nation. Look at the history of the Bush family: first they backed the Nazis, now it’s the Saudi’s and next it will be whomever we can profit from the most. This is not state action, it’s international corporate greed managed by patrician extremists and their fanatic religious friend–just like the “states” we’re fighting in the continued war of terror.

    Reply

  7. Matthew says:

    I with Levy were Israel’s PM or a US Senator. He has the courage to say what American politicians will not: You will not have a solution to the Israeli/Palestinian conflict until you recognize the legitimate aspirations of the Palestinians. Our politicians act like Israel is a modern day John Rockefeller, giving away charity to the unwashed. This attitude–that Israel is doing the Palestinians a favor–feeds Israeli self-denial and Palestinian rage. the NAF has a good addition in Levy.

    Reply

  8. Carroll says:

    I don’t know of any quote that exposes Israel’s true intent, what all their actions have been and are about and exposes their excuses as lies any better than this. Every single sentence is a dead giveaway.
    “We know from listening in to conversations between Hamas members that they have given up firing up Qassam rockets. They finally get it. If they fire one off, they usually hit nothing at all — and one of their guys gets his head blown off. We know they don’t do it now. It’s Islamic Jihad that continues to be a problem, but they are disorganized and Hamas one of these days will deal with them. But we know that these guys in Hamas are ultimately rational and aren’t all out to martyr themselves.”

    Reply

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *