Beyond Hubris: US Military Finally Gets Robert Pape’s Message

-

jaffe washington post.jpg(photo credit: Greg Jaffe of Washington Post; see his photo essay)
Greg Jaffe has a fascinating piece in the Washington Post today highlighting recognition by the US military that it blew it in Afghanistan’s Korengal Valley.
The insurgents there were fighting for not some radical cause — but against American occupation.
This “occupation is the problem” theme is Robert Pape‘s message about the main dynamic that drives suicide bombing and violent insurgency.
From the Washington Post:

KORENGAL VALLEY, AFGHANISTAN — It was as if the five years of almost ceaseless firefights and ambushes had been a misunderstanding — a tragic, bloody misunderstanding.
More than 40 U.S. troops have been killed, and scores more wounded, in helicopter crashes, machine-gun attacks and grenade blasts in the Korengal Valley, a jagged sliver just six miles long and a half-mile wide. The Afghan death toll has been far higher, making the Korengal some of the bloodiest ground in all of Afghanistan, according to American and Afghan officials.
In the pre-dawn hours of Wednesday, the U.S. presence here came to an abrupt end.
A day earlier, Capt. Mark Moretti, the 28-year-old commander of American forces in the valley, walked two dozen Korengali elders around his base and told them that the United States was withdrawing. He showed the elders the battle-scarred barracks, a bullet-ridden crane, wheezing generators and a rubber bladder brimming with 6,000 gallons of fuel.
Moretti, the son of a West Point physics professor, and Shamshir Khan, a valley elder whose son had been jailed for killing two U.S. troops, sat together on a small wall near the base’s helicopter pad. In keeping with local custom among friends, they held hands.
Moretti gently reminded Khan of the deal they had reached a few days earlier: If U.S. troops were allowed to leave peacefully, the Americans wouldn’t destroy the base, the crane and the fuel. Khan assured him that the valley’s fighters would honor the deal.
“I hope that when I am gone, you will do what is best for your valley and the villagers,” an almost wistful Moretti said.
“I want you to travel safely to your home, to your family,” the 86-year-old elder replied. He gazed at the officer through thick glasses that magnified rheumy brown eyes and beamed.
Over the previous week, hundreds of U.S. Army Rangers and Afghan commandos had pushed into the valley to control the high ground the enemy would need for a big attack on departing troops. Dozens of cargo helicopters hauled off equipment. By Wednesday morning, the last Americans were gone.
For U.S. commanders, the Korengal Valley offers a hard lesson in the limits of American power and goodwill in Afghanistan. The valley’s extreme isolation, its axle-breaking terrain and its inhabitants’ suspicion of outsiders made it a perfect spot to wage an insurgency against a Western army.

And just keep in mind that at current levels the US is spending more than $100 billion in military expenditures alone in a country with a GDP of just $12 billion.
Money is not buying success in Afghanistan.

— Steve Clemons

Comments

5 comments on “Beyond Hubris: US Military Finally Gets Robert Pape’s Message

  1. Jerry says:

    Korengal and other outposts represent the Bush mentality long since dicredited after the advice of the Baker Hamilton commission which advocated a different approach in Iraq. Yet, at the same time, Bush ignored the troops in Afganistan knowing full well that he not they would soon go away.

    Reply

  2. PissedOffAmerican says:

    “Maybe progressives can push obama into ending his imperialist corporatist war on terror by
    surrendering to allah’s law, it would send a
    powerful signal to the muslim world that america is on their side and usher in world peace and harmony”
    So here we see some jackass, admitting through sarcasm, that in his esteemable opinion and bigoted mindset this is in all actuality a war against Islam. Worship Allah?? Well, obviously you must be a terrorist then.
    I wonder what the hell he suggests we do?
    Undoubtedly, if honest, he would say “Kill all the Muslims.”
    But thats not to be compared with a nazi saying “Kill all the Jews”. Nope. Not at all similiar. Uh uh.

    Reply

  3. JohnH says:

    So far it’s not clear what would make the US stop fighting in Afghanistan. There are no metrics, only ‘we’ll know progress when we see it.’ And for this we spend $100 Billion per year? It would make as much sense for the military to spend $100 Billion barking at the moon!

    Reply

  4. INFIDEL says:

    The insurgent commander quoted in the story you
    linked to said they’ll stop fighting if the
    americans surrender to god’s law and stop fighting
    for man law, not if they leave.
    Maybe progressives can push obama into ending his
    imperialist corporatist war on terror by
    surrendering to allah’s law, it would send a
    powerful signal to the muslim world that america is
    on their side and usher in world peace and harmony.

    Reply

  5. JohnH says:

    Well, duh! “The insurgents there were fighting for not some radical cause — but against American occupation.”
    The US military may have “gotten it” in this one instance. But I doubt that the military has really “gotten it.” And US policy makers and their underwriters, merchants of death, have definitely not “gotten it,” since their $100 Billion annual gravy train depends on their not getting it.

    Reply

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *